Let's Talk About the Elephant in the Jewelry Box
You've got pieces you love. The ring that made you cry (happy tears). The watch your dad wore on his best days. The necklace you bought yourself because you earned it.
And right now, they're either sitting uninsured on your nightstand or buried somewhere inside your homeowners policy where "coverage" is a generous word.
That's not protection. That's a false sense of security with fine print.
You shouldn't have to choose between wearing your favorite pieces and worrying about them.
I'm Lenny. Protecting Your Jewelry Is About More Than the Jewelry.
I'm Lenny Burton, CLU. I'm an independent agent, which means I work for you, not for a carrier. My job is to look at your whole picture and spot the risks before they become problems.
Here's one I see all the time: someone has beautiful jewelry sitting on their homeowners policy, and they have no idea that filing a claim on it could raise their home premium or even cost them their policy. That's not a risk worth taking with the coverage that protects your entire home.
So I do something about it. I move that risk where it belongs, onto a standalone jewelry policy built for exactly this. For my clients' jewelry, I use BriteCo, and here's why I trust it:
- It's all-risk coverage designed specifically for fine jewelry and watches, not a one-size-fits-all add-on.
- BriteCo doesn't report jewelry claims to the CLUE or A-PLUS loss-history databases (more on what that means below).
- It's backed by an AM Best A+ rated carrier, so the financial strength is there when you need it.
You shouldn't have to lose sleep over the jewelry you love. I make sure you've got the right coverage in the right place, so a lost ring stays a small problem instead of a big one.
BriteCo earned my recommendation for a reason. It was founded by a third-generation retail jeweler and GIA Graduate Gemologist who got tired of watching people overpay for underwhelming coverage, and it's been recognized across the board: #1 Best Overall Jewelry Insurance by NerdWallet, Best for Replacement Value with a perfect 5-star rating by Forbes, and among the Best of 2025 by CNBC Select. Policies are underwritten by Glencar Insurance Company, an AM Best A+ rated carrier backed by global reinsurer Hannover Re, and licensed in all 50 states and Washington, D.C.
Why work with me:
- Independent agent, not captive. I shop for what's right for you.
- CLU (Chartered Life Underwriter), advanced training in holistic risk management and financial planning, so you get advice on the whole picture, not just a single policy.
- Available by text, email, or a scheduled call. Your call.
Three Steps. Zero Headaches. One Happy Jewelry Collection.
Tell Us What You've Got
Select your piece type (ring, necklace, watch, bracelet, earrings, the whole treasure chest) and enter the appraised value. Takes about 60 seconds. We won't judge your collection. (Okay, we might silently admire it.)
Answer a Few Quick Questions
We keep underwriting simple. Most customers only answer five or six basic questions. No blood samples. No lie detector. No faxing anything to anyone. Ever.
You're Covered
Choose monthly or annual billing, and your jewelry is protected. Worldwide, all-risk, zero deductible.* That's it. Go wear your ring to brunch without that little knot in your stomach.
This Is What Better Coverage at a Better Price Actually Looks Like
- $0 deductibles on most policies. File a claim, get your piece repaired or replaced, keep your wallet in your pocket. (Agreed Value Policies may have a deductible. See your policy contract for details.)
- Worldwide coverage, 365 days a year. Your ring is protected in Paris, Poughkeepsie, and everywhere in between. No territorial restrictions.
- All-risk protection. Loss, theft, damage, and mysterious disappearance. Yes, "it just vanished" is a covered event.
- Coverage up to 125% of your appraised value. Because replacement costs don't always match your original appraisal, especially when gem and metal prices fluctuate.
- Automated annual value updates. BriteCo adjusts your coverage based on current market prices so you don't have to chase down a new appraisal every year.
- Preventative maintenance coverage. Prong retipping, broken or worn prongs, broken earring posts, clasp replacement, pearl strand restringing, and stone tightening. Because a loose prong today is a missing diamond tomorrow.
- Convenient monthly payments. Premiums typically run 0.5% to 1.5% of your jewelry's appraised value per year. For many customers, that's less than $5/month for an engagement ring.
- Add a partner or fiance at no extra charge. Because love shouldn't come with a surcharge.
- No claims reporting to CLUE or A-PLUS. BriteCo is the only specialty jewelry insurance provider that specifically does not report claims to these loss-history databases. That means a jewelry claim through BriteCo stays with BriteCo.
Your Homeowners Policy Is for the Big Stuff. Keep It That Way.
Your homeowners policy is there for hurricanes, tornadoes, fires, the things that really matter. That's what it's built for, and that's where you want it working for you when you need it most.
Here's the not-so-secret secret: a jewelry claim on your homeowners policy can put all of that at risk. Why let a missing ring complicate your coverage for the things that protect your entire home?
Moving your jewelry to its own standalone policy keeps your homeowners record clean and gives your jewelry the kind of specialized coverage it actually needs. Here's what that looks like:
| Homeowners Floater | BriteCo | |
|---|---|---|
| Deductibles | Common, often $500+ | $0 always* |
| Claims reported to CLUE / A-PLUS | Typically yes | Never** |
| Mysterious disappearance | Often excluded or restricted | Covered |
| Coverage territory | Restrictions may apply | Worldwide |
| Appraisal updates | You handle them manually | Automated annually |
| Coverage cap | Often $1,000 to $2,500 sub-limits | Up to 125% of appraised value |
*Zero deductible applies to standard BriteCo policies. Not applicable for agreed value policies.
**BriteCo does not report jewelry claims to CLUE or A-PLUS loss-history databases. A claim through your BriteCo policy stays with BriteCo and will not affect your homeowners insurance premiums, eligibility, or future underwriting. Claims filed on a homeowners rider or floater are typically reported to these databases by the homeowners insurer, which could potentially impact your homeowners premiums or renewal status. BriteCo cannot guarantee the specific practices of any individual homeowners insurance company. Consult your homeowners insurer directly to understand how they handle claims reporting.
The bottom line: Filing a jewelry claim on your homeowners policy can follow you around for up to seven years in those databases. With BriteCo, your jewelry claim is just a jewelry claim. It doesn't touch your home insurance record.
Don't Take Our Word for It. Take Theirs.
Questions You're Probably Thinking Right Now
How much does it cost?
Less than you think. Get your free quote here and find out in about 60 seconds. No commitment, no credit card. Discounts are available for annual payment, home safe storage, and central burglar alarms.
What do I need to get a quote?
Just the type of jewelry (ring, watch, necklace, etc.) and its appraised value. The whole quote process takes about 60 seconds. You'll need an appraisal, detailed sales receipt, or lab certificate to finalize the policy. If you purchased the piece recently, a detailed receipt may be enough.
What does "mysterious disappearance" actually mean?
It means if your ring is just... gone (no break-in, no dramatic heist, just gone) you're still covered. Many homeowners policies don't cover this scenario.
Will filing a claim affect my homeowners insurance?
BriteCo does not report claims to CLUE or A-PLUS loss-history databases. A claim through your BriteCo policy stays with BriteCo and will not affect your homeowners insurance premiums, eligibility, or future underwriting. This is one of the biggest reasons people move their jewelry off their homeowners policy.
Who underwrites BriteCo policies?
All policies are underwritten by Glencar Insurance Company, an AM Best A+ rated carrier, backed by global reinsurer Hannover Re. That's one of the highest financial strength ratings in insurance.
Can I insure multiple pieces?
Absolutely. Add as many items as you'd like: rings, watches, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, loose stones, heirloom pieces, you name it.
Can I use my own jeweler if I need a repair or replacement?
Yes. BriteCo works directly with your preferred jeweler to ensure your piece is replaced with the exact same quality and specifications.
Your Jewelry Didn't Ask to Live Dangerously.
You spent time choosing it. You spent money on it. You wear it because it means something. Now give it the coverage it deserves, in about the time it takes to pick a Netflix show.
Better coverage. Better price. Zero deductibles.* Zero drama.
Get My Free Quote Now → Call (772) 675-5433No commitment. No credit card needed for a quote. Just a fast, free price check.
This page provides a general, informal description of the coverages and benefits available through BriteCo jewelry and watch insurance policies. It is not a contract of insurance. All coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions set forth in the actual policy contract. Please refer to your policy documents for complete details regarding your coverage. Availability, terms, and pricing may vary by state.
All policies are underwritten by Glencar Insurance Company, an AM Best A+ rated insurance carrier. BriteCo, Inc. is a licensed insurance agency in all fifty states and the District of Columbia.
*Zero deductible applies to standard BriteCo policies. Not applicable for agreed value policies. See your policy contract for full details.
**BriteCo does not report jewelry claims to CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) or A-PLUS (Automated Property Loss Underwriting System) loss-history databases. Claims filed through a homeowners insurance rider or floater are typically reported to these databases by the homeowners insurer. However, BriteCo cannot guarantee the specific claims reporting practices or underwriting decisions of any individual homeowners insurance company. For questions about how your homeowners insurer handles jewelry claims, contact your homeowners insurance provider directly.
Trustpilot rating and editorial rankings (NerdWallet, Forbes, CNBC Select) reflect information available as of the date of publication and may change. Individual experiences may vary.
"Save up to 40%" claim, where referenced, is based on a comparison of BriteCo premiums against typical homeowners floater and competitor standalone jewelry insurance rates as cited in independent reviews. Actual savings depend on individual circumstances including item value, location, and coverage history.
Premium estimates are for illustrative purposes only. Coverage costs are subject to underwriting review and approval according to actual policy terms and conditions. Rates may vary based on a number of factors, including value and primary location.